Monday, June 4, 2012

News of the Week: 04 June 2012




Don't have time to read 50+ fishing and tackle collecting blogs and web sites? Well, let us do it for you! Follow all of the latest news, articles, and stories on our Whitefishpress Twitter account! Hint: You don't need to be a member...just bookmark the Twitter Feed Page or click on latest links to the right!

Remembering the Proctor fly...a new 'Bama rig hits the streets...Brits are excited about opening day...students wrangle big catfish...father faces jail time for pretending to catch frozen fish...help Sam Drukman, noted rodmaker, in his time of need...a new book by Richard Stoll...the more lures change, the more they stay the same....is this the greatest fish tale of all time?...it must be the NEWS OF THE WEEK!

THE MONDAY 10: The Ten Fishing Stories of the Week You Need to Know

The Big Lead: Remembering the Proctor, an old brook trout fly.

Another 'bama rig clone is about to hit the market…



The British are itching for opening day.


Students wrangle big catfish from river.


Father faces jail time for pretending to catch frozen fish.

Help rodmaker Sam Drukman in his hour of need.


A lesson in lures.

Richard Stoll's new book gets profiled.

The more lures change, the more they stay the same.



Finishing with a Flourish: Is this the most incredible fishing tale of all time?



-- Dr. Todd

Sunday, June 3, 2012

1000 Words

1000 Words

Jack Sharkey was a former professional boxer and heavyweight champion of the world. He was active during the "Golden Age of Boxing" and is the only person who ever fought both Jack Dempsey and Joe Louis, losing to the former when he turned his head to complain to the ref about a low blow and got knocked out and getting demolished by Louis in his final fight in 1934, which saw him get knocked out in the 3rd round. In between he fought and lost the title to both the German Max Schmelling and the Italian Primo Carnera. His record of 38-14-3 is a bit deceptive; he fought in a hugely competitive era and in addition to victories over Schmelling and Carnera, counted wins over legendary fighters Harry Wills, Tommy Loughran, and Jack Delaney (all champions in their day), as well as draws with former champions Mickey Walker and Tom Heeney.

Unlike so many professional boxers, Sharkey saved his money and invested well, and spent the majority of his retirement fishing. He often appeared at sportsman's shows, where he would give demonstrations on fly casting. Here is a press photo from the late 1930s showing Sharkey after some saltwater fish.



-- Dr. Todd

Saturday, June 2, 2012

Deconstructing Old Ads: Walter Willman and the P-41 (1947)


Walter Willman and the P-41

Walter Willman was a very successful Tournament caster with both the fly rod and the bait casting rod. Between 1922 and 1938 Walter won nine national championships in Dry fly accuracy, 5/8 oz accuracy, 5/8 oz distance and 3/8 oz distance. Walter had a reputation for being able to build and tune bait casting reels for tournament use. After World War II, he became a consultant for the Heddon Company and designed a light weight bait casting reel for them known as the “Pal P-41."  It was produced for Heddon by the Bronson Reel Company and featured a removable head ring that screwed off for easy lubrication on the gears and bearings. The first of these reels were produced in 1947 and were aluminum in color. They had the usual screws that held the head plate on when the head ring was removed.


The reel was popular among tournament casters. Somewhere along the way it was discovered that if one removed all the screws in the head plate and left the head ring in place, the reel stayed assembled and functioned normally. By 1950 several changes were made eliminating the head plate screws and giving the reel an attractive dark maroon (always listed as black) anodized finish. In addition, a lighter narrow-spool version of the reel designated the P-41N was introduced. According to Tournament Casting historian Cliff Netherton:

"The narrow spool version was outstanding for accuracy casting and the wide spool P-41 was the most popular reel for Skish Bait casting. It was the reel used to set the Skish Bait Distance records in the 1950's”

The ad featured here is from the June 1951 issue of Sports Afield and touts the P-41's recent records at casting tournaments.


The 1950 Heddon Catalog also featured a seldom seen version of the P-41 identified as the P-41S. It is a saltwater or heavy service version that is made from chrome plated brass and is definitely much heavier in the hand. In 1952 there was a short-lived economy version introduced, the P-51, that was green in color. It was more cheaply made and did not have the same anti-backlash feature as the standard P-41's. In 1954 the two standard P-41's were offered along with a hand tuned, extra light version known as the P-41L. It cost twice the price of the standard P-41's and featured gold anodized trim and extra light, hollowed out gears. The catalog cautioned that the reel “should not be used for heavy fishing” and said it was excellent for tournament accuracy and distance casting. By 1957 an additional narrow spool version of this deluxe lightweight reel was also offered designated the P-41NL. 1959 was the last year that Heddon cataloged the P-41's. There are no bait casting reels in the 1960 catalog.


Gold trimmed P-41L on the left and standard P-41N on the right

My personal experience with the P-41's can be summed up as follows. They are fun to cast, especially the P-41N which, on a long soft action rod, will handle 1/5 ounce with little difficulty. I have not had good experiences with either the standard width or the narrow spool reels when attempting to fish with them. Both reels have "locked up" while playing large fish. I recently acquired the two deluxe lightweight P-41L's but after having the afore mentioned problems with the standard weight reels, I believe I'll just follow the Heddon catalog's advice and not take them fishing!



-- Bill Sonnett

Friday, June 1, 2012

The Friday Funhouse

Video of the Week

Montauk guide Bill Wetzel describes the mother of all striper schools.



12 Things I Would Buy If Only I Could Afford Them

This 1950s Staro Swiss spinning reel is pretty darn neat looking.


Vintage large Geen's patent spoon is a great British lure.


You don't see many Horrocks-Ibbotson reels in boxes like this.


1937 has one of my favorite Heddon catalog covers.


This set of three is awesome Fin Nor salmon reels.



This Talbot Premier #3 is an awesome reel.


Wow, is this Moonlight musky minnow sweet!


This Nichols fly rod is super, duper rare.



A black A&I split shot tin is a tough find.


This "00" by Heddon is an iconic bait.


A 4 Bros. "Neverfail" in the box is a fine Pflueger lure.



One of my all-time favorite lures: the Arbogast Snake.



As always, have a peaceful weekend, and be nice to each other--and yourself.

-- Dr. Todd

Thursday, May 31, 2012

Thursday Review: Art Dollosso's Where Trout Sing and Other San Francisco Stories

Reading Where Trout Sing and Other San Francisco Stories, the new book by California fly angler and author Art Dollosso, is like sitting around a campfire listening to a master story teller weave a series of overlapping tales. I swear at times I can actually here the hissing and popping of the fire while absorbing the engaging prose that makes this book so entertaining.


Books like this rarely get published these days, and that isn't just a shame--its a damn shame. There was a time fifty or more years ago when books like this would have been published several times a year, and one could fill in the gaps between good fly fishing writings by gleaning the pages of Field & Stream, Hunting & Fishing, and National Sportsman for the latest exploits of Lee Wulff or Ray Bergman.

No more, at least when it comes to magazines. However, a few writers like Dollosso and fellow Californian John Parmenter have sought in recent years to resurrect these autobiographical fly fishing epistles that so many of us devoured in years past.

Dollosso's path to fly fishing was not easy. Growing up in a tough part of San Francisco, where most of the stories take place, he took to fly fishing early -- or perhaps it's best to say that fly fishing took him early. All the evidence one needs to support this particular theory can be found in the chapter "Dan Bailey's Vest," a charming story about Dollosso as a young man and the expensive fly angler's vest he purchased with the kind of toil and sacrifice only a teenager who's friends were tossing rocks in the river and cracking wise with the girls while he was delivering papers can understand. He writes of his beloved Dan Bailey vest:

It is safe to say an angling accoutrement is not quite like, or as sentimental as, that first kiss, or that first love. Yet it does have meaning, like a long life, or hope. Pass it on.

Aspiring fly angling writers take note. This is how you write without pretense about a sport all too full of pretentious snobs.

I could go on, about his take on opening day, about the peculiar Italian-American community in San Francisco where he came of age, of his tough childhood that keeps pulling him back like a magnet, helping him to make sense of the present and the man that he became. But that would be spoiling it, and Dollosso is a writer who should be read in a comfortable chair on a quiet evening when the kids are sleeping over and the spouse has gone to bed. In a perfect world, you would have a hunting dog curled up at your feet and a double finger of a single malt by your side.

(Just so you don't think I'm a pretentious snob, while reading this book I had a half-Australian cattle dog/half long haired dachshund rescue dog snoring away on the couch next to me, and a glass of orange juice to drink. True story.)

If you like writing in ALL CAPS, strings of expletives in place of descriptive dialogue, gratuitous "grip and grin" fishing photos and other tropes of the internet generation of fly angling scribes, I'm afraid you probably won't like Art Dollosso's writing. Too each their own. But if you're looking for a book that deftly melds autobiography, history, fly fishing, and the meaning of life, than you will love Where Trout Sing.

It's been a really good couple of years for books like this, but we who love this kind of writing should not become overconfident. We should celebrate every single time a book like Where Trout Sing gets into print. They are too few and far between to grow complacent.

Art Dollosso is a great story teller and has written a charming book that transcends its California setting.

This hardcover (with dust jacket) book is privately published and is 163 pages in length. It has a brief foreword by fly fishing icon Russell Chatham, and is available exclusively through Jim Adams at Adams Angling in San Francisco. The price is $24.95 and Jim offers free shipping. You can contact him at the link above or by calling 510-849-1324.

-- Dr. Todd

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Ben Wright's Spinning Reel Report (May 2012)

MAY 2012

SPRING HAS SPRUNG WITH SOME PRETTY HIGH PRICES PAID ON THE BAY !!!

Featured Reel:
An Australian CEDER SEAMARTIN that looked to be in exc + condition sold @$ 1,675.00
I can't help but wonder if this is the same reel that was found at a flea market their not long ago. it was bought for $50.00

A few HIGH priced reels:
Allocks Superb ewb @ 182.50
Zebco cardinal 3 second version nib @ 330.00
Alcedo Micron later version w/curved leg nib @ 305.01
Orvis 50A FB exc- @ 315.99

ABU:
Garcia Abu-matic 170 CF ewb @ 86.00
Suveran S4000M nib @ 265.00
Abu (not Garcia) 505 scf nib @ 177.49
Cardinal 6X e-wb @ 234.00

English:
J. W. Young Ambidex Deluxe exc @ 141.97
A rare Bercol parts reel, missing parts @ 210.09

French:
Centaure Pacific exc- @ 77.01
Ru Pacific nib @ 77.00
Luxor Saumon mer e+wb @ 78.77

Italian:
Orvis 75A nib @ 178.49
Holliday 30 second version e+wb @ 182.50
Holliday 40 first version exc @ 193.50
Holliday 30 first version e+wb @ 247.58
Zangi Pelican 75 exc+ @ 250.00
Cargem 55 steel head paint wear @ 234.00

Mitchell:
498X Pro Annun. exc- @ 316.12
508 w/rod exc but rod tip was replaced @ 710.00
common 304 e+wb @ 80.79
408 e+wb @ 152.00

Penn:
BLACK 710 nib @ 250.00
Green 710 e-wb @ 62.25

Zebco cardinals:
3 first version exc @ 277.00
3 second version exc+ @ 167.51

Other reels:
Shakespeare scf 1785 exc- @ 29.99
Airex Astra ewb @ 15.50
Johnson Century 100B CF e+wb @ 42.00
Swiss Benora e+wb @ 77.55
and a FB 202 flip reel salt water wear @ .01 and thats not a type-O
Ben

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

News of the Week: 28 May 2012




Don't have time to read 50+ fishing and tackle collecting blogs and web sites? Well, let us do it for you! Follow all of the latest news, articles, and stories on our Whitefishpress Twitter account! Hint: You don't need to be a member...just bookmark the Twitter Feed Page or click on latest links to the right!

The Bud Snyder collection is profiled...one tackle shop owner tells some stories...British ire is up over salmon netting...why you should balance your tackle...bass fishing in Lodi...fishing turf war brewing between Georgia and South Carolina...build a better tube fly...Michigan's Operation Healing Waters...film makers get profiled...so does Toledo luremaker Dennis Bryant...it must be THE NEWS OF THE WEEK!

THE MONDAY 10: The Ten Fishing Stories of the Week You Need to Know

The Big Lead: Bud Snyder collection gets profiles…at a million dollars?!?


One tackle shop owner's vast inventory and insight give his venue atmosphere and history.

The Brits are in a huff over early salmon netting.


Why you should balance your tackle.


Bass fishing in Lodi is off the hook.


Why a fishing turf war is brewing between Georgia and South Carolina.


How to build a better tube fly.


Nifty article on Michigan's Operation Healing Waters Fly Fishing.


Kiwis behind the film Once in a Blue Moon get profiled.


Finishing with a Flourish: Dennis Bryant of Toledo--noted luremaker--gets profiled.



-- Dr. Todd

Monday, May 28, 2012

A Memorial Day (Re)Post

A Memorial Day (Re)Post

Today you may be expecting the News of the Week. However, here at Fishing for History we never work on Memorial Day. Instead, I want everyone to reflect on the meaning of this holiday. For too many, it is just a convenient day off from work. But the reality of the matter is that this is a day when everyone should reflect on what it means to be an American.


As I was driving through Indianapolis yesterday on my return trip back home, I looked up in the sky and saw four planes flying in formation. It was the Blue Angels, getting ready for their fly by at the start of the Indianapolis 500. As I listened to the invocation at the start of that great race on the radio, it struck me that those of us interested in fishing history have as much to remember and memorialize as everyone else.

It was, after all, Civil War veterans like Capt. Thos. H. Chubb who helped found many of the tackle companies in the wake of that great conflagration that first popularized the sport of fishing. It was men such as Major Charles Conover of the Kansas City wholesale hardware firm of Richards & Conover that helped distribute this tackle across this expanding nation. And it was the host of veterans who, seeking a moment of solitude to forget the horrors of war, turned to the peaceful art of angling by the legion. It did not matter which side you fought on; fishing was the great equalizer.

In the wake of the Spanish-American war, noted firms such as the Shakespeare Company and Abercrombie & Fitch--who hand-tailored Col. Teddy Roosevelt's personal uniform--plied the growing nation with the tackle it needed and desired. But it was really the First World War that transformed fishing. Returning veterans in 1918 and 1919 created the greatest demand for fishing tackle to that point in the nation's history, and a plethora of companies ranging from Thos. E. Wilson (who created a special fund to care for the families of employees at Wilson Meatpacking who were wounded or died in the war) to the ever-present Winchester Repeating Arms Company entered the fishing tackle field with a grand flourish.

Fishing and the Second World War is a subject of great interest and one I plan on penning a significant work on one day. But suffice to say the contributions of tackle makers was extremely valuable, as noted tackle makers made everything from the Norden Bomb Sight to survival kits. One manufacture--Montague Rod & Reel Company--made everything from bamboo ski poles to intricate firing pins for machine guns, all under the same roof. It was not unique. Back home, the tackle makers like Creek Chub and Pflueger continued to advertise, press for the purchase of war bonds, and remind Americans that brighter days were ahead. And in the wake of the war, returning veterans once again kick-started the American fishing industry and propelled angling to a position as the most popular past time in America.


Hand-made lure fashioned by US Navy Sailor during WWII from an oil tin, engraved with various stops across the Pacific.

So no News of the Week today--you can come back tomorrow for that. Today we remember the sacrifices necessary to preserve our freedoms. My father came back from the war and the occupation of Japan to start a family and fish once again. Others were not so lucky and their absence is still felt today. Is it too much to ask that one day every year we remember the contributions of soldiers past and present?

Have a safe and happy Memorial Day.

-- Dr. Todd

Sunday, May 27, 2012

1000 Words

1000 Words

This week in 1000 Words, we get a nifty picture of a man very important to the tackle industry, but who's impact is almost universally overlooked: J.G. Taylor Spink. Spink was the owner of the famed Sporting News, but was also the publisher of the Sporting Goods Dealer. It was in the pages of the Sporting Goods Dealer where new tackle was always introduced to buyers and companies big and small. It is not an understatement to say that only a handful of people impacted the tackle business as much as Spink. Here he is ca. 1930s fishing from a boat.



-- Dr. Todd

Saturday, May 26, 2012

Deconstructing Old Ads: Artistic?…Simplex?…Simple? (1907)


Artistic?…Simplex?…Simple?

There are many ads for the Heddon Artistic Minnow that appear in outdoor magazines through out the year 1907. This one is from the July 1907 issue of National Sportsman. It is difficult to find an ad for the Heddon Artistic Minnow in a magazine from any other year. You will also find the Artistic Minnow only in the 1907 Heddon Catalog. It may have been in the 1908 catalog but that is one of two early Heddon catalogs that have never been found. The other missing catalog is 1904.
 


There was much conjecture at one time as to where the name “Artistic” came from including the story that Heddon possibly had the bodies made by the Artistic Wood Turning Works in Chicago. Words go in and out of style and at the turn of the last century the term “Artistic” was a commonly used term meaning “refined, cultivated or in good taste.” In this case using this small wooden minnow was supposed to represent the height of refinement, the same way a dry fly fisherman thinks of himself as someone more cultivated or refined than a bait fisherman. The Artistic Minnow, despite being small, is listed at 1/2 oz. and came with a weighted buoy that was to aid in casting as 1/2 oz. was then thought of as a very light weight bait. It is even suggested that the bait could be handled successfully on a fly rod. The very idea of slinging a 1/2 oz bait around on a bamboo fly rod makes me cringe!

The Artistic Minnow presents several mysteries in my mind. Occasionally, an Artistic minnow is found with two or three belly weights. I have no explanation for this other than a special order as these are somewhat rare and I have never had a chance to weigh one. Another mystery is that the bait was only offered for a short time then was gone forever to be replaced in 1909 by the first model of the Heddon #20. That first #20 used an identical sized body and came in the same small maroon colored boxes as Artistic Minnows. Upon close inspection, almost all of the small maroon boxes for the earliest Heddon #20 prove to be overlabeled Artistic Minnow boxes. An explanation for the Artistic Minnow's short run is found in a 1927 interview with Will Heddon that was published in the Clermont Press, Clermont, Florida.


Asked what was the most popular bait ever marketed Mr Heddon said, “Styles in our business change as completely and just as quickly as women's clothing. I remember one bait that I perfected in a lake north of Minneola which had only small fish in it, knowing that this bait would sell well in the North where many fishermen are glad to catch any Bass that escapes the legal length. This bait met with a wonderful reception. We were unable to meet the demand, but by spurring production finally were able to catch up with orders for it. Suddenly the public fancy veered and we were caught with 50,000 of this one model on our shelves. We finally sold them to a wholesaler for 10 cents each taking a heavy loss on them that ate up our profits during the time they were in vogue.

In my mind this explanation of the Artistic Minnow's short life contains the answer to another supposed mystery. It has been stated (in print) that the Heddon Artistic Minnow is virtually indistinguishable from the Pflueger Simplex Minnow. Every possible theory has been posed to explain "perceived" differences. The very few Pflueger Simplex's I have seen (less than ½ dozen) are obvious Pflueger products. The paint jobs, the gill marks, the hardware and overall appearance all scream “Pflueger” to me. I personally have never seen one of the “Artistic” appearing baits show up in the wild in a Pflueger box. If it did happen I would suggest that Pflueger simply purchased the “wholesaled” Artistics and put them in their boxes. It would certainly be cheaper than making them themselves. The first pair of pictures below show a true Pflueger Simplex Minnow and box paper. These photos are compliments of NFLCC member Wayne Benson. The second set shows a Heddon Artistic Minnow and a copy of the Artistic Minnow box papers.




Heddon Artistic Minnow:




You be the judge!

-- Bill Sonnett

Friday, May 25, 2012

The Friday Funhouse

The Video of the Week

A nifty video on the history of the Needlefish style saltwater lure, by Dennis Zambrotta.



12 Things I Would Buy If Only i Could Afford Them

This neat 1902 Vom Hofe reel with leather case is a great find.


A Fin Nor Model 3 Spinning Reel is a fantastic reel.


This neat Worden Combination Minnow is a beautiful lure.


It's not often we get to feature a Bronson reel, but this Biltwell in a classic art deco box is a nice example of an early reel.


This Thos. J. Conroy reel with case is as nice a trade reel as you'll find.


This nice pair of Frank Mizera decoys are fine examples of this legend's work.


This H.L. Leonard salmon reel is about as nice a reel as you'll find this year.


When's the last time you saw a Jack Welch Heddon 3-30 tournament reel for sale?


A Shakespeare 5-hook muskie minnow is a massive chunk of wood.


My favorite eBay photo of the year: Big Boy Pikie.


Who wouldn't like a nice musky revolution from Shakespeare?


Moonlight Seagulls are great lures.



A Jim Donaly Redfin in the box is about as nice as they come.



As always. have a safe weekend and bee good to each other, and yourself.

-- Dr. Todd